Newspaper Ad Sparks Controversy

  • August 21, 2013
  • Editor: Sun Xi
  • Change Text Size: A  A  A

A full-page advertisement in a major Guangzhou newspaper imitating a woman gloating over an extramarital affair, but which is actually part of a cosmetic brand's campaign, stirred up heated debate and was canceled, with claims it is a challenge to social morality.

The advertisement, which looks like a letter, was printed on August 20, 2013 in Southern Metropolis Daily, a major newspaper in the capital of Guangdong province.

The fictitious writer, who refers to herself as Mrs Zhang, asks Zhang's ex-wife to let him go and gives her advice on how to find her own Mr Right.

"Excellent men only belong to a woman who can present herself well. May you wake up as early as possible and learn how to best present yourself. May there be no mistresses anymore," the ad reads.

Fu Yisu, a public relations manager with Canton Fair E-commerce Co, said: "Is the newspaper promoting the success of a mistress? I was very surprised to read the ad. It poses a great challenge to traditional morality."

However, Li Hu, deputy market managing director of Southern Metropolis Daily, said the content of the ad had been carefully examined prior to its publication.

"Actually, it is a commercial ad, promoting a cosmetics brand. The content is in line with related advertising laws," Li told China Daily.

Li said the ad is part of a series to be printed over seven days.

A marketing manager at Nanfang Daily, which administers Southern Metropolis Daily, said on condition of anonymity that a South Korean cosmetics company signed a contract with the newspaper to print the advertising series.

"Newspapers, which have seen sluggish market performance in the last two years, sometimes have to attract readers and clients by printing such stunning ads," she said.

However, late on Tuesday, the provincial industrial and commercial bureau said it has ordered the newspaper and the cosmetic company to stop running the advertisement to prevent negative social impact.

The commercial violates the advertising law as it "violates good social conventions", it said.

Chinese newspapers' advertising revenue is expected to drop in the coming years, challenged by the increasing coverage of digital media, according to industry experts.

In 2011, the nation's online advertising revenue exceeded that of newspapers for the first time as more advertisers began looking to Web media platforms such as search engines, along with commerce and video websites, according to Beijing-based market research firm iResearch.

According to the China Advertising Association, Chinese newspapers' advertising revenue dropped 7.3 percent year-on-year in 2012.

Xie Liang, a veteran commentator with Radio Guangdong, said: "China's surging online advertising market has been a boon for advertising platform providers. But this time, the advertisement in Southern Metropolis Daily proved that traditional print media can still find the right clients by printing innovative ad content."

The ad quickly spread to Sina Weibo, China's biggest micro-blog platform, and WeChat, a mobile messaging application.


comment on this story

Messages that harass, abuse or threaten others; have obscene or otherwise objectionable content; have commercial or advertising content or links may be removed.

    • I am interested to know how Chines women feel about their opportunities for business ownership in mainland China. Prefer an English response, but Chinese is welcome, THXBrad Glass from Ohio
    • Chairman Ma Zedong once said that in China women uphold half of the sky. I am preparing an invited editorial on healthcare in women in China and would like very much to quote his saying in Chinese in his own calligraphy. I wonder if you would be ab ...Professor Tsung O. Cheng, M.D. from Washington, D.C., U.S.A.
    • Dear Mrs Mr I have found a picture on your site of Karen Mok Karen Mok (Mo Wenwei)[Photo source: I am wondering if I can use this photo for job that I am doing for a Branding book. The book and power point presentation is only ...Charlotte Therme-Lindell from Netherlands
    • Hello ! your article ( Traditional Chinese Meals for New Mothers Popular in New York September 18, 2013 by Mo Peiwen) mentioned that a certain Zhou (in Flushing Chinatown in Queens, New York) supplies meals to chinese mothers in Queens, Brooklyn and ...margaret from new york USA
    • I am thinking of taking an Opportunity to work in China,hopefully in Shanghai for a few Years or 3.I know the Company I work is own by an Hong Kong Business Family and is call Wilson Security and Parking..I am work as Security Officer and Reception F ...Ngar Rairoa from Sydney Australia
    • Hi Friends,Im Ngar from Sydney.First time here and I love China so much.Shanghai is my favourate City and I cant wait to go back.Oh Chinese womens are Beautiful and Loyal.I finally got myself a QQ email and so hard to get on Chinese Website.Would be ...Ngar Rairoa from Sydney Australia
    • Hello, l've gone through your site and interested in working together, or affiliate my NGO with yours, so as to work as one. l wish you can establish a hospital here in Ghana. which l have land for this project. Can you please let me know if it po ...Ama Konadu from Ghana
    • I am a PhD graduate in Chinese Studies at Minzu University of China and University of Naples L'Orientale (dual degree), specialised in contemporary Chinese studies.I would like to ask you if you could kindly provide me the email address of Prof. L ...Alessandra Cappelletti from Italy
    • Hello everyone, my name is Agorastos Papatsanis and I am an worldwide award professional nature photographer (specialize in mushrooms - fungi). I want to travel in China to take pictures from Dictyophora indusiata (bamboo forest). You wrote a grea ...Agorastos from Greece
    • My Question : Can I get contact details and email address for Ms Hong Ju? or Can you give me email address for the President of Women of China? Need it urgently. Thanks Ainaaainaa from Malaysia
      • Our Chinese Dream
      • 银川妇女
      • Top 10 Gender Events in 2013
      • 2014 National March 8th Red-Banner Pacesetters